10 Unassuming Florida Restaurants Serving the Best Steaks, According to Locals

Florida is renowned for its sandy beaches and vibrant nightlife, but nestled within its charming towns are hidden culinary gems that cater to steak enthusiasts. These unassuming restaurants, cherished by locals, offer some of the finest steaks the Sunshine State has to offer. From rustic dining rooms to Brazilian-style feasts, each venue brings a unique twist to the classic steak dinner.

Whether you’re drawn to the nostalgic charm of a retro steakhouse or the bold flavors from global influences, Florida’s steak scene promises a savory journey. Discover why these ten spots are celebrated by those who know them best.

1. Chima Steakhouse (Orlando)

Orlando’s Chima Steakhouse offers a dining experience that’s both theatrical and delectable. Here, gauchos elegantly parade through the dining room with skewers of sizzling, perfectly grilled meats. Patrons can indulge in an endless array of cuts, each more tantalizing than the last.

The atmosphere is lively yet sophisticated, making it ideal for both casual meals and special celebrations. Guests rave about the picanha, a Brazilian favorite, which melts in your mouth.

Pairing the meats with a selection of traditional sides like pão de queijo enhances the feast, crafting a memorable culinary journey that brings the flavors of Brazil to Florida.

2. Andre’s Steak House (Naples)

Andre’s Steak House in Naples is a nostalgic escape into the past, serving steaks in a setting reminiscent of a ’70s time capsule. Locals cherish this spot for its steadfast dedication to quality and tradition.

The focus here is on simplicity, with tender, flavorful steaks prepared using time-honored techniques. The filet mignon is a standout, noted for its juiciness and rich taste.

This no-frills establishment may eschew modern flair, but it delivers on the essentials. It’s a testament to the timeless appeal of a perfectly cooked steak, making diners feel like they’ve discovered a well-kept secret.

3. Peter’s Steak House (Jensen Beach)

In Jensen Beach, Peter’s Steak House combines beachy charm with culinary excellence. The relaxed atmosphere invites patrons to unwind and savor steaks that are expertly cooked to perfection.

Locals appreciate the ribeye, which bursts with flavor, complemented by the laid-back vibe that permeates the restaurant. The decor is casual and inviting, making it perfect for a leisurely meal.

Every visit to Peter’s feels like a special occasion, thanks to the warm service and consistent quality. It’s a hidden treasure where the focus remains on delivering a satisfying steak experience that’s beloved by its community.

4. The Back Room Steakhouse (Apopka)

The Back Room Steakhouse in Apopka offers a unique ambiance that feels right out of a classic film-noir. This hidden gem boasts an intimate setting where steaks are the star of the show.

Guests are treated to expertly cooked cuts, each marinated and seasoned to highlight their natural richness. The New York strip is particularly popular for its robust flavors.

The moody atmosphere, coupled with attentive service, creates an experience that feels both exclusive and welcoming. It’s a destination for those seeking a dining adventure without leaving their hometown comforts.

5. Saltgrass Steak House (Orlando)

In Orlando, Saltgrass Steak House brings a taste of Texas to Florida with its bold flavors and relaxed setting. Known for its signature-seasoned steaks, this restaurant offers a hearty meal that satisfies every carnivore.

The casual yet lively atmosphere is a hit among diners who appreciate the robust, smoky notes of the steaks. The sirloin, seasoned to perfection, is a must-try.

With generous portions and a warm, welcoming ambiance, Saltgrass seamlessly combines the spirit of Texas with Floridian hospitality. It’s a place where comfort and bold taste come together harmoniously.

6. Cattle Ranch (Sanford)

Cattle Ranch in Sanford stands as a testament to the power of simplicity done right. This family-owned establishment has built its reputation on serving huge, flavor-packed steaks that need no embellishment.

The T-bone steak is a favorite among regulars, known for its tenderness and robust taste. The restaurant’s no-nonsense approach is reflected in its straightforward decor and emphasis on quality.

Here, the focus is on delivering an authentic steakhouse experience that feels like home. It’s a beloved spot where friends and family gather to enjoy a meal that’s both hearty and satisfying.

7. Old Hickory Steakhouse (Kissimmee)

Nestled in Kissimmee, Old Hickory Steakhouse offers a refined experience with its rustic charm and upscale flair. This resort-side restaurant is celebrated for its aged-to-perfection steaks that exude richness and depth.

The bone-in ribeye is a standout, offering a luscious and decadent taste that lingers. The dining room’s elegant ambiance makes it ideal for special nights out.

Locals frequent Old Hickory for its impeccable service and attention to detail. It’s a place where the art of steak grilling is taken seriously, and every visit feels like an occasion to remember.

8. Embers Wood Grill (Gainesville)

Embers Wood Grill in Gainesville defies its modest exterior with an upscale interior that delights diners with its wood-fired cuisine. Known for smoky steaks that impress, it’s a favorite among serious foodies.

The filet, grilled over wood embers, offers a depth of flavor that’s both nuanced and robust. The strip-mall location adds to its unassuming charm.

Inside, the elegant setting provides a contrasting backdrop to the exterior, enhancing the dining experience. It’s a destination for connoisseurs who appreciate the intricate balance of smoke and meat.

9. Salento Steakhouse (Jacksonville)

In Jacksonville, Salento Steakhouse brings a global twist to traditional steakhouse fare with its Colombian-inspired menu. The hacienda-style decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere that draws diners in.

The churrasco, a Colombian favorite, is a must-try, offering a refreshing take on familiar flavors. The influence of Colombian cuisine adds a unique flair to each dish.

Salento is a place where cultural heritage and culinary excellence intersect, providing a dining experience that’s both comforting and exotic. It’s a beloved spot where locals gather to enjoy a taste of something different.

10. Okeechobee Steakhouse (West Palm Beach)

Okeechobee Steakhouse in West Palm Beach is a legend in its own right, known as Florida’s oldest steakhouse. This iconic venue continues to impress with its richly flavored dry-aged steaks.

The porterhouse, dry-aged to perfection, is a favorite among patrons seeking a traditional steakhouse experience. The decor harks back to a bygone era, adding to its timeless appeal.

With a history that spans decades, Okeechobee has perfected the art of steak preparation. It remains a cornerstone of the local dining scene, cherished for its unwavering commitment to quality and tradition.