8 Hidden Florida Spots Serving the Best Crab Cakes You’ll Ever Taste
Florida, known for its stunning beaches and vibrant culture, also boasts a hidden treasure trove of culinary delights, particularly when it comes to crab cakes. Away from the bustling tourist hotspots, local gems offer a gastronomic experience that captures the essence of the state’s seafood charm.
Whether nestled by serene waterways or tucked in bustling neighborhoods, these spots offer unique twists on the beloved crab cake. From spicy Cajun influences to classic buttery textures, each location brings something special to the table. Explore these eight lesser-known culinary havens and discover why Florida is a true paradise for crab cake enthusiasts.
1. High Tide Harry’s (Orlando)
High Tide Harry’s in Orlando is a testament to the magic of simplicity in seafood. This family-run establishment, with its nautical charm, focuses on crafting crab cakes that are thick and golden, bursting with authentic lump meat.
The seasoning is expertly balanced, enhancing the natural sweetness of the crab without overpowering it. Visitors often find themselves lost in the homely atmosphere, where maritime décor evokes the feeling of dining by the sea.
Despite its location away from the ocean, this spot proves that exceptional seafood doesn’t need an ocean view. High Tide Harry’s is a must-visit for those seeking genuine crab cake perfection.
2. Salt Shack On The Bay (Tampa)
At Salt Shack On The Bay in Tampa, sunsets and crab cakes create the perfect pairing. This vibrant spot offers jumbo lump crab cakes that are all flavor and zero filler, ensuring each bite is a burst of pure seafood indulgence.
Surrounded by beach vibes and swaying palm trees, diners enjoy an atmosphere that feels like a tropical retreat. The waterfront views add a serene backdrop to the culinary experience.
Known for its commitment to quality, Salt Shack delivers crab cakes that resonate with both locals and visitors, making it a cherished spot for those seeking a taste of the sea.
3. Riggins Crabhouse (Lantana)
Riggins Crabhouse in Lantana is where locals gather for an authentic seafood experience. The unassuming blue building hides a treasure trove of culinary mastery, with crab cakes that are buttery and meaty.
Cooked to a perfect crisp, these cakes offer a rich taste that speaks of tradition and skill. Riggins is devoid of pretension, focusing instead on delivering quality that speaks for itself.
The welcoming atmosphere matches the stellar reputation of its crab cakes, making this spot a beloved gem for those in the know. A visit here is an invitation to savor the understated elegance of real seafood.
4. The Dancing Crab (Altamonte Springs)
The Dancing Crab in Altamonte Springs brings a vibrant twist to Florida’s crab cake scene with its Cajun flair. These crab cakes are packed with spice and flavor, creating a taste sensation that celebrates the Gulf Coast.
Lively and energetic, the restaurant’s atmosphere mirrors the bold flavors of its signature dish. Each bite feels like a joyous celebration of seafood and spice.
The fusion of Cajun influences with Florida freshness makes this spot a unique culinary destination. It’s where tradition meets innovation, offering an unforgettable taste adventure for those eager to explore new flavors.
5. Rick’s Reef (St. Pete Beach)
Rick’s Reef in St. Pete Beach is a laid-back haven where the elegance of crab cakes meets beach shack comfort. Flip-flops are welcome in this relaxed setting, where the food truly shines.
The crab cakes are a standout feature, bursting with lump meat and exuding seaside charm. Their five-star taste is a delightful surprise in such a casual environment.
Visitors come for the easygoing atmosphere but stay for the exceptional seafood. Rick’s Reef offers a unique blend of informality and culinary excellence, making it a cherished spot for those seeking genuine flavors.
6. Florida’s Seafood Bar & Grill (Cocoa Beach)
Florida’s Seafood Bar & Grill in Cocoa Beach is more than its iconic pink exterior. Inside, the focus is on thick, pan-seared crab cakes that are big on crab and low on filler.
Each serving is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality, drawing beachgoers back time and again. The cakes are expertly crafted, ensuring the crab’s natural sweetness is the star.
The vibrant setting and coastal charm enhance the dining experience, making it a must-visit for seafood lovers. Here, flavor and freshness unite in perfect harmony, offering a true taste of Cocoa Beach.
7. Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar (Sarasota)
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar in Sarasota has earned its reputation as a Gulf Coast staple through decades of dedication. The crab cakes here are legendary, rich and tender, setting the gold standard for seafood excellence.
The bustling atmosphere is a testament to its popularity among locals and tourists alike. Each cake is crafted with care, offering a melt-in-the-mouth experience that is hard to rival.
Captain Curt’s is more than a restaurant; it’s a Sarasota institution. Its commitment to quality and flavor ensures that diners leave with a taste of the Gulf they won’t soon forget.
8. The Boathouse (Lake Buena Vista)
The Boathouse in Lake Buena Vista offers a touch of sophistication to the crab cake experience. Situated near Disney, it combines waterfront dining with indulgent seafood.
The crab cakes are perfectly seared and buttery, rivaling any coastal catch. Diners enjoy a luxurious setting where each bite is an indulgence.
Whether visiting for the view or the cuisine, The Boathouse promises an experience that delights the senses. It’s a place where culinary artistry meets the magic of its surroundings, making it a memorable destination for those craving a gourmet encounter.
