Florida is home to some seriously amazing ice cream shops, and if you’re craving a banana split, you’re in luck. From old-school parlors with retro vibes to trendy spots with wild flavors, the Sunshine State has it all.
Whether you want a classic three-scoop sundae or something totally over-the-top, these local favorites will satisfy your sweet tooth in the best way possible.
1. Bruster’s – Oviedo, FL
Fresh ice cream made daily is what sets Bruster’s apart from the rest. Every batch is crafted on-site, so you know you’re getting dessert at its absolute peak. The banana split here features classic scoops nestled between perfectly ripe banana cuts, topped with all the fixings you’d expect.
Families love this spot for its welcoming vibe and generous portions. Kids go wild for the rainbow of flavors, while parents appreciate the quality and consistency. It’s the kind of place where everyone leaves happy.
2. Andy’s Frozen Custard – Sanford, FL
Frozen custard isn’t just ice cream—it’s richer, creamier, and way more indulgent. Andy’s has perfected the art of custard-making, and their banana split showcases that smooth, velvety texture beautifully. Each spoonful feels like a little celebration in your mouth.
You can customize your split with different custard flavors and sauces, making each visit a new adventure. Locals rave about the freshness and the friendly service.
If you’re in Sanford and want something beyond ordinary ice cream, Andy’s delivers big time.
3. Sea Maids Creamery — Tampa, FL
This whimsical, mermaid-themed creamery serves some of Tampa’s most indulgent banana splits. With ultra-creamy ice cream and fun toppings, it’s the kind of treat that makes you feel like a kid again. The playful atmosphere adds to the magic, making every visit feel special.
Sea Maids doesn’t just serve dessert—they create an experience. The bright colors, ocean vibes, and friendly staff make it a must-visit for families and ice cream lovers alike.
4. Main Street Creamery — Sarasota, FL
This charming Sarasota shop is known for ultra-rich homemade ice cream and picture-perfect sundaes. Their banana split stands out for its balanced flavors and high-quality ingredients. Nothing feels rushed or mass-produced here—just honest, delicious dessert done right.
Main Street Creamery takes pride in crafting ice cream that’s smooth, flavorful, and made with care. The banana split is a showcase of their commitment to excellence, with every element working in harmony. You can taste the difference quality makes.
5. Ice Screamin’ — Tampa, FL
With fun, bold flavors and super creamy textures, Ice Screamin’ has a loyal following for a reason. Their banana split is fully customizable, letting you build the ultimate sundae your way. It’s ice cream on your terms, and that’s what makes it so special.
Whether you want classic vanilla or something wild, the options are endless. The staff is helpful and enthusiastic, guiding you through the choices without overwhelming you.
Tampa residents love Ice Screamin’ for its creativity, quality, and the freedom to experiment with flavors.
6. Sampaguita Ice Cream — Orlando, FL
A Filipino-inspired creamery celebrated for its unique flavors and silky texture. You’ll discover flavors you’ve never tried before, and they’ll quickly become favorites.
Sampaguita brings cultural richness to every scoop, blending tradition with innovation in the most delicious way. The ice cream is impossibly smooth, and the flavor combinations are both surprising and comforting.
7. Abracadabra Ice Cream Factory — Kissimmee, FL
Known for its flash-frozen ice cream magic, Abracadabra turns desserts into a show. Their banana split is over-the-top, customizable, and perfect for families looking for fun with their sweets.
Watching your ice cream get made right in front of you adds an extra layer of excitement to the experience. Kids are mesmerized, and parents are impressed.
Located in Kissimmee, this spot is ideal for tourists and locals who want dessert with a side of entertainment.
8. Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream — Orlando, FL
Loved for its small-batch charm and rotating seasonal flavors, Kelly’s has become an Orlando staple. Their banana split is fresh, fun, and perfectly balanced, making it a go-to for locals.
Kelly’s takes pride in crafting ice cream that feels homemade in the best way. The flavors change with the seasons, so there’s always a reason to stop by. The banana split is a canvas for whatever delicious creations they’re featuring.
Orlando residents consider Kelly’s a neighborhood treasure that never gets old.
9. Jaxson’s Ice Cream Parlor & Restaurant — Dania Beach, FL
One of Florida’s most iconic ice cream spots, Jaxson’s is famous for its huge portions and retro atmosphere. Their banana split is legendary—big, bold, and perfect for sharing (or not!).
Walking into Jaxson’s is like entering an ice cream lover’s dream, complete with nostalgic decor and endless menu options. Everything about this place screams fun, from the quirky decorations to the enthusiastic staff. It’s not just dessert—it’s an experience you’ll remember.
Located in Dania Beach, Jaxson’s has been delighting visitors and locals for decades.
