The Best Bagels in Florida, According to People Who Are Picky About Bagels
Finding a truly great bagel in Florida might seem impossible, especially if you grew up eating them in New York or New Jersey. But the Sunshine State has quietly become home to some seriously impressive bagel shops run by people who understand what makes a bagel worth eating.
From beachside bakeries to neighborhood cafes, these spots are earning praise from even the pickiest bagel lovers who know the difference between a real bagel and a bread roll with a hole in it.
1. Tiki Bagel – St. Pete Beach, FL
Picture this: you’re still rubbing sleep from your eyes, the Gulf breeze is cool, and you’re holding a warm, perfectly chewy bagel from a little beachside bakery. That’s the magic of Tiki Bagel.
This spot has earned a serious reputation among locals who refuse to settle for mediocre breakfast. Every batch is baked fresh daily, with that ideal texture—crispy on the outside, soft and dense on the inside. It’s the kind of place where you grab your order and head straight to the sand.
2. Bagels & Brews Cafe – Sarasota, FL
Some mornings, you don’t need anything fancy—just a hot bagel, a good cup of coffee, and a place where the staff knows your order by heart. Bagels & Brews Cafe nails that vibe perfectly.
Tucked into a Sarasota neighborhood, this cafe has become the go-to spot for people who appreciate simplicity done right. The bagels come out hot, the coffee is strong, and there’s zero pretension. Regulars love the no-fuss approach and the fact that everything tastes homemade without trying too hard.
3. Jeff’s Bagel Run – Orlando, FL
Ask any Orlando local where to get the best bagel, and Jeff’s Bagel Run will come up every single time. This place has earned cult status for one simple reason: the bagels are that good.
Every bite delivers that perfect chew—not too soft, not too dense, just right. People drive across town for these bagels, and they’re willing to wait in line because they know it’s worth it.
Jeff’s has become more than just a breakfast spot; it’s a local institution where bagel standards are set high and consistently met.
4. Brooklyn Dough – Naples, FL
When a New Yorker moves to Florida and starts craving a real bagel, they usually end up disappointed—until they find Brooklyn Dough. This Naples bakery brings authentic Brooklyn-style bagel-making to Southwest Florida, and the difference is obvious from the first bite.
The dough is made using traditional methods that give these bagels their signature texture and flavor. It’s chewy, substantial, and tastes like it came straight from a Brooklyn bakery. The owners clearly understand what makes a bagel legit, and they refuse to cut corners.
5. LMB Baking Co. – Punta Gorda, FL
Small-batch baking means every bagel gets the attention it deserves, and that’s exactly the philosophy at LMB Baking Co. This Punta Gorda shop keeps things simple and fresh, baking bagels in small quantities throughout the day.
Locals love the grab-and-go convenience without sacrificing quality. Each bagel is made with care, and you can taste the difference. The shop has built a loyal following of customers who appreciate that fresh-baked feel and the fact that nothing sits around getting stale.
It’s proof that you don’t need a huge operation to make exceptional bagels—just dedication and good ingredients.
6. Brandon Bagels – Brandon, FL
This classic local spot serves up breakfast favorites with consistency that keeps people coming back day after day. The bagels are fresh, the sandwiches are generously made, and the vibe is comfortably familiar. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your face and your usual order.
For Brandon residents, this isn’t just a bagel shop—it’s a morning ritual and a community hub rolled into one delicious experience.
7. Beachside Bagel World – Satellite Beach, FL
Satellite Beach has its own hidden gem for bagel lovers who want quality without the wait. Beachside Bagel World keeps things relaxed and straightforward, serving warm bagels that hit the spot every time.
The bakery embraces that easy coastal vibe—nothing fancy, just good food made right. Customers appreciate the quick service and the fact that the bagels taste fresh-baked, not mass-produced. It’s perfect for grabbing breakfast before hitting the waves or fueling up for a beach day.
8. Bagel Babe Co. – St. Petersburg, FL
St. Pete’s food scene has exploded in recent years, and Bagel Babe Co. fits right into the city’s creative, trendy vibe. This spot isn’t afraid to have fun with flavors while still respecting what makes a bagel great.
The shop has quickly built a loyal following thanks to its inventive takes on classic bagels and spreads. Locals love the playful energy and the fact that the bagels themselves are legitimately good, not just Instagram bait. The texture is on point, and the flavor combinations actually work.
9. The New York Bakery Boys – Kissimmee, FL
When you walk into The New York Bakery Boys, you immediately know these folks aren’t messing around. The bagels here are big, bold, and unapologetically Bronx-style—exactly what homesick New Yorkers dream about.
Everything about this place screams authentic, from the size of the bagels to the way they’re prepared. The owners brought their New York roots with them, and it shows in every bite. Customers rave about finally finding bagels that remind them of home, with that perfect chew and substantial heft.
10. Jersey Girl Bagels – Bradenton, FL
New Jersey takes its bagels seriously—arguably even more seriously than New York—and Jersey Girl Bagels brings that Garden State pride straight to Bradenton.
The shop doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel; it just makes bagels the right way, using techniques and recipes that honor East Coast tradition. Customers who grew up eating Jersey bagels can finally stop complaining about Florida’s bagel scene because this place gets it right.
It’s a little slice of the Northeast in Southwest Florida, and bagel purists couldn’t be happier about it.
11. Stuff a Bagel – Windermere, FL
Sometimes you want more than just a bagel with a schmear—you want a meal that’ll keep you full until dinner. Stuff a Bagel understands this perfectly, loading up bagel sandwiches with generous portions that don’t quit.
This Windermere spot has built its reputation on hearty, satisfying breakfast sandwiches that use quality bagels as the foundation. Customers love the no-skimping approach and the fact that every sandwich feels like you’re getting your money’s worth.
12. Pete’s Bagels – St. Petersburg, FL
St. Petersburg has become a serious foodie destination, and Pete’s Bagels fits perfectly into that scene. This popular hangout combines thoughtful craftsmanship with creative spreads that elevate the bagel experience without losing sight of what matters most—the bagel itself.
The shop has earned a devoted following thanks to its attention to detail and willingness to experiment while respecting tradition. Each bagel is made with care, and the creative spreads add personality without overshadowing the main event.
