7 Florida Pizza Shops Serving Chicago’s Other Famous Pizza: Crispy, Square-Cut Tavern Style
Chicago’s most-eaten pizza at home isn’t the famous deep dish. It’s a thin, cracker-crisp pie cut into little squares instead of wedges.
That square cut is called a party cut or tavern cut. The corner pieces are tiny, crunchy, and fought over at the table. I love that a pizza can start arguments with its shape alone.
Here’s my favorite surprise. You don’t have to fly north to get one. Florida has a growing handful of shops that make this style with real care, from takeout counters to family-owned pizzerias.
I went looking for the ones that take the crunch seriously. Some come from homesick Chicagoans, some from brothers, and one even started as a food truck. So which corner piece are you grabbing first?
1. Brad’s Underground Pizzeria
A pizza shop with underground in its name sounds like a secret club. Luckily, the only password here is your order.
Brad’s Underground Pizzeria is a takeout-focused spot in Orlando built around Chicago pizza. Deep dish gets plenty of attention, but the tavern-style thin crust is the quiet star for crunch lovers.
Plenty of Chicago fans don’t realize the thin pie is even on the menu. Once they find it, it tends to become a habit. That’s a good problem to have.
The deep dish is known for a buttery, flaky crust and a thick layer of cheese. Seasoned sausage and a rich sauce round it out. So you can bring home both styles and settle the family debate in one trip.
Why order both? Tavern-style pizza is what many Chicagoans actually eat on a normal weeknight. Deep dish is more of a special occasion pie, so having both feels like a full Chicago tour.
Timing matters here. The shop is closed Mondays and opens at 4 PM Tuesday through Saturday, with an earlier 11:30 AM start on Sundays.
Friday and Saturday hours stretch to 10:30 PM. That makes it handy for a late movie night on the couch.
Parking is easy, with a free lot and street spots nearby. Delivery is also an option when the couch wins the argument.
Address: 4400A Curry Ford Rd, Orlando, FL 32812
2. Nick’s Pizza Co.
Square-cut, cracker-crust, and very Chicago. Jacksonville has a pizza shop that speaks fluent tavern style.
Nick’s Pizza Co. keeps things simple. It’s a takeout and delivery operation, so plan on eating at home, at a park, or in your car if you’re impatient.
The crust is the headline here. Think thin and crisp, cut into squares so you can grab small pieces without committing to a giant slice.
Italian beef sandwiches share the spotlight. That pairing is classic Chicago comfort food, and it’s not easy to find in North Florida.
An Italian beef is thin-sliced roast beef piled on a roll with its juices. Pick one up with your pizza, and dinner turns into a full Windy City feast.
Hours are a little particular, so check before you head out. Nick’s is closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
Wednesday, Thursday, and Saturday start at 4 PM. Friday and Sunday open at noon, which makes a weekend lunch possible.
Here’s a practical tip. The parking lot can get tight, so a quick pickup plan helps.
Call ahead or order online, then swing by. Reservations aren’t a thing here, and there’s no dine-in seating anyway.
Catering is also available. That’s a smart move for game day or a birthday party.
A table full of tavern squares beats a stack of floppy slices. Your guests can graze all afternoon.
Address: 9766 Old St Augustine Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32257
3. Mad Pizza
Two friends, Mat and Dustin, founded this Hollywood pizzeria, bringing family pizza recipes and a love of crunchy crust to the menu. Sibling teamwork never tasted so crisp.
Mad Pizza serves Chicago tavern-style thin crust that’s crispy, cheesy, and loaded with flavor. Chicago transplants often compare it to the pizza they grew up eating back home.
That’s high praise from people who know their squares. Homesick fans don’t hand out compliments lightly.
You can sit down here, which is nice. The room is casual, with table service, a kids’ menu, and high chairs for little pizza critics.
Sports fans get screens to watch. Some nights even bring live music, so dinner can come with a soundtrack.
Plant-based eaters aren’t left out. Mad Pizza offers vegetable toppings and customizable pizzas, but diners seeking vegan options should confirm available cheese and crust ingredients before ordering.
That’s rare for a tavern-style shop. It means your whole group can share the table without anyone settling for a side salad.
Hours run from 4 PM to 9:50 PM on weekdays. Saturday and Sunday open earlier at 11 AM, perfect after a morning near the beach.
Want a calmer visit? Thursday nights tend to be the quietest.
Weekend evenings and Sunday afternoons usually get busier. Curbside pickup helps if you’d rather skip the wait.
Street parking is paid but usually available. Bring a little patience and a big appetite for corner pieces.
Address: 211 N 21st Ave, Hollywood, FL 33020
4. Windy City Pizza
Hand-rolled sausage is the kind of detail Chicago pizza fans notice right away. Delray Beach gets it right on Atlantic Avenue.
Windy City Pizza is a neighborhood eatery with a big Chicago heart. The thin crust bakes up crisp, and the sauce leans bright and tangy.
Sausage is the move here. It comes hearty and flavorful, with generous cheese holding everything together.
Looking for a bold pick? The Papa Pepperoni Pizza is a signature on the menu.
Italian beef shows up too, along with wings. That trio covers just about any Chicago craving you can name.
The location makes this stop extra fun. West Atlantic Avenue puts you close to downtown Delray’s strolling and shopping.
Grab a pie before or after a walk. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside.
Families will feel at home. Kids are welcome, high chairs are ready, and the vibe stays casual and friendly.
Groups can relax since reservations are accepted. That’s handy for team parties or birthday dinners.
Hours run 11:30 AM to 9:30 PM, Tuesday through Sunday. The restaurant closes on Mondays.
Wednesday afternoons and Thursdays tend to be busier. Plan around those if you want a quicker seat.
Address: 401 W Atlantic Ave, Delray Beach, FL 33444
5. 3 City Pizzeria
Chicago, Detroit, and New York walk into a pizzeria. The punchline is lunch in Fort Myers.
3 City Pizzeria is locally owned and serves three famous pizza styles under one roof. That makes it a great pick for groups who can’t agree on anything.
The Chicago thin crust is the reason it’s on this list. South Side natives living in Southwest Florida have called it the best tavern pie around.
Fun fact: the business has roots as a Chicago-style food truck. The food truck menu featured thin crust, deep dish, meatballs, and garlic knots.
Today, you can still find Chicago favorites like the Italian beef sandwich and wings. Detroit’s thick, square pies and New York’s foldable slices round out the lineup.
The space has a mom-and-pop feel with good music playing. It’s casual enough for a quick bite and friendly enough to linger.
Vegetarian diners can ask about suitable pizza options, while vegan diners should confirm the available ingredients and substitutions before ordering. Dogs are allowed, which is a nice bonus for pet owners.
Plan carefully, because hours are lunch-and-early-dinner friendly. Doors open at 11 AM and close at 8 PM.
That schedule runs Tuesday through Saturday only. Sundays and Mondays are closed.
McGregor Boulevard makes for an easy drive. Parking is free and usually plentiful.
Address: 12901 McGregor Blvd #5, Fort Myers, FL 33919
6. Hillary’s Chicago Pizza St. Augustine
Imported Italian sausage is the secret weapon at this St. Augustine pizzeria. It gives the tavern pie that hard-to-describe Chicago flavor.
Hillary’s Chicago Pizza serves both deep dish and thin crust. The 16-inch thin crust arrives cut and presented the traditional Chicago way.
That means squares, of course. A big round pie turned into a grid of crunchy bites is great for sharing.
Love deep dish too? You can order that here, and it holds its own beside the thin pie.
The Chicago Italian beef sandwich is another standout. Ask about it if you’ve never tried one.
The room adds some fun. Video games give the space a playful edge, and the mood stays casual and family-friendly.
Sports fans can catch a game while they eat. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside.
Vegan and vegetarian menus mean nobody has to sit out. Happy hour food is also on the schedule.
Visiting the oldest city in the nation? This spot on US1 makes an easy stop after a day of sightseeing.
Hours run noon to 9 PM, Wednesday through Saturday. Sunday closes earlier at 7 PM.
Mondays and Tuesdays are closed. Parking is free, with an on-site lot and street spots.
Address: 1974 US1, St. Augustine, FL 32086
7. AT’s A Chicago Pizza
Out in the Florida Panhandle, one family is serving up a slice of Chicago. Squares included, no snow required.
AT’s A Chicago Pizza is family-owned and makes both deep dish and tavern-style thin crust. It’s a rare find in this part of the state.
Fans call it the best Chicago thin and deep dish in the Panhandle. Ordering both is a popular way to test that claim yourself.
So which should you choose? Go thin if you love crunch and easy sharing.
Choose deep dish if you want a knife-and-fork kind of night. Better yet, split one of each with friends.
Freeport sits near Choctawhatchee Bay, not far from the beaches of South Walton. That makes this a smart dinner stop on a Gulf Coast vacation.
Service is counter style and quick. The atmosphere is casual and quiet, which is nice after a loud beach day.
Groups are welcome, and kids fit right in. You can dine in or grab your pizza to go.
Delivery isn’t offered, so plan to pick up. Free parking helps make that easy.
Hours run 3 PM to 8 PM, Tuesday through Friday. Saturday opens at 11 AM and closes at 8 PM.
Sundays are short, from 11 AM to 4 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.
Address: 1245 Old Jolly Bay Rd, Freeport, FL 32439







