This Little Florida Amish Country Store Is Packed With Old-Fashioned Treasures You Won’t Find at Walmart
Black mangrove honey sits on the shelf here, right next to Dutch Kettle apricot jam. That pairing alone tells you this shop plays by different rules than the big-box stores.
The jam lineup runs deep, with seedless and sugar-free options plus fruit butters like cinnamon apple. Then come the farm fresh eggs, rolled butter, cheeses, and raw milk. I like how a single stop covers breakfast, snacks, and a few gifts.
This little Florida store also stocks bee pollen, noodles, popcorn kernels, and honey from nearby Auburndale. It feels like a pantry your great-grandmother would approve of. I believe that kind of place is getting harder to find.
So what else is waiting on those shelves? Grab a basket, because the honey is only the beginning of the story.
1. Honey Lovers Should Clear Some Room in the Cupboard
Honey is the headliner at Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse, and the name makes no secret of it. The shelves hold a wide range of varieties, so choosing just one jar can feel like a fun little test.
Orange blossom honey from Auburndale shows up here, which keeps things wonderfully local. That town sits just down the road, so the bees basically work in the neighborhood.
Black mangrove honey is another variety you might spot. It comes from a coastal tree, and it’s not something most grocery chains bother to carry.
Raw honey is a big part of the appeal too. Many shoppers seek it out because it isn’t heavily processed before it reaches the jar.
Allergy blends have also appeared on the shelves over the years. Some folks like trying local honey during pollen season, though it’s smart to chat with your doctor about health questions.
My advice is simple. Grab one familiar flavor and one you’ve never heard of, then do a taste test at home.
You might end up with a new favorite for toast, tea, or straight off the spoon. Nobody’s judging the spoon method here.
2. A Jam Wall That Makes Grape Jelly Look Shy
Strawberry and grape are fine, but they’re just the warm-up act. The jam and jelly selection here goes much further, and it’s one of the main reasons people make the trip.
Dutch Kettle apricot jam is one example you can find. Dutch Kettle is a brand known for an old-fashioned, small-batch style that fits this store perfectly.
Fruit butters deserve their own spotlight. Cinnamon apple butter is a smooth, spiced spread that tastes great on biscuits, pancakes, or even a simple slice of bread.
Shoppers watching their sugar have choices too. The store carries sugar-free options, so more people at the table can enjoy something sweet.
Seedless varieties are also on hand for anyone who hates picking tiny seeds out of their teeth. That small detail can make a big difference for kids.
Flavors can shift with the seasons, so the lineup may look a little different each visit. That makes repeat trips more interesting.
Here’s a tip. Buy a few small jars and set up a breakfast tasting board with crackers and butter.
3. Your Breakfast Plate Is About To Get an Upgrade
Eggs might be the sneaky star of Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse. Jumbo eggs are a popular pick, and sometimes the store even has flats with double yolks.
Double yolks aren’t guaranteed every day, though. The owner has offered to hold a flat for shoppers who ask, which is a nice personal touch.
Rolled butter is another breakfast treasure. It comes shaped in a log instead of neat little sticks, and it has a real farmhouse look.
Cheeses join the lineup too, along with a few meats. Grass-fed chicken has been listed among the items, giving dinner a boost as well.
Put those pieces together, and you’ve got a serious morning menu. Fresh eggs, a pat of butter, and a drizzle of honey on toast sounds pretty unbeatable.
Bring a small cooler if you live a bit of a drive away. Florida heat and butter are not best friends.
Plan your meals around what you buy, and you’ll stretch the fun all week. Scrambled, fried, or baked into cookies, those eggs will earn their spot.
4. Raw Milk and Other Finds You Won’t Spot in Big Chains
Walk past the jam and you may find raw milk, a specialty product that Florida law permits retailers to sell only when labeled for animal consumption, not human consumption.
Big supermarket chains generally don’t carry it. That alone makes this little Florida shop a go-to stop for folks who want that option.
Raw milk is unpasteurized and can contain harmful bacteria, including E. coli, Salmonella, and Listeria. Florida prohibits its sale for human consumption, and refrigeration does not eliminate these risks.
Bee pollen is another specialty item on the shelves. People sprinkle it on yogurt, oatmeal, or smoothies for a little crunch and color.
CBD oil is also available for adults who are curious about it. As with anything wellness related, a quick talk with a doctor is a smart first step.
Yoder tonic has shown up on the shelves as well. It’s the kind of name that makes you pick up the bottle just to read the label.
These products give the store a true country-pantry personality. Explore slowly, read labels, and ask questions if something catches your eye.
5. Pantry Staples With a Throwback Twist
Grandma’s pantry called, and it wants its noodles back. The shelves here are full of everyday basics that feel a little more homemade than usual.
Egg noodles are a classic Amish-style favorite. They’re thick and hearty, which makes them great for chicken soup or buttered noodles on a busy night.
Popcorn kernels are on hand for movie nights. Popping them on the stove is a fun, old-fashioned activity, and kids love hearing that first pop.
Canned goods fill out the selection too. Salad dressings line up nearby, adding easy flavor to weeknight dinners without any extra effort.
Fried green tomato mix is another item the store has stocked. That’s a true Southern comfort food, and it’s fun to try at home with fresh green tomatoes.
Shopping for basics here turns a chore into a small adventure. You might come in for honey and leave with a full dinner plan.
A good strategy is making a short list before you go. Then leave room for one surprise item, because there will definitely be one.
6. Old-School Sodas Worth Hunting Down
White birch soda is not exactly a Florida grocery store regular. Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse has been one of the few places in the state to carry it.
Birch soda has a minty, crisp flavor that’s a little like root beer’s cousin. It’s especially popular in Pennsylvania, so seeing it down South feels like a fun surprise.
Old-fashioned sodas like this are more than drinks. They bring back memories for people who grew up with them, and they spark curiosity for everyone else.
Try pairing a cold bottle with some popcorn made from kernels picked up in the same shop. That’s a snack combo with real throwback charm.
Stock can change over time, so it’s never a bad idea to call ahead if you’re craving something specific. Small stores rotate items often.
For a road trip, grab a few different bottles and let everyone rank them. It’s a cheap way to make the drive home more entertaining.
Just remember to keep them chilled. Warm soda is a sad soda, no matter how cool the label looks.
7. Friendly Faces Make the Shelves Even Sweeter
Size isn’t everything. This shop is smaller than some people expect, but it makes up for it with a big selection packed into a cozy space.
Friendly staff is one of the most talked-about parts of the experience. Shoppers often mention being greeted as soon as they come through the door.
That small-store feel lets you ask questions without feeling rushed. Wondering which honey works best in tea? Just ask.
The owner also responds to feedback and has even offered to hold items for customers. That kind of attention is rare in giant chain stores.
Prices are a topic people discuss, since specialty foods can cost more than mass-produced ones. Many shoppers feel the quality matches what they pay.
A good approach is to treat the visit like a tasting adventure. Pick a few special items instead of filling a whole cart.
Also, it helps to know that the store carries Amish-style goods rather than being Amish-run. Setting that expectation makes the visit more enjoyable and keeps the focus on the great products.
8. Mark Your Calendar Before You Hit the Road
Timing matters here more than you might think. Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse keeps a schedule that’s a little unusual, so planning ahead pays off.
The store is open Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Saturday hours are shorter, running from 1 to 5 p.m.
Wednesdays and Sundays are closed. Showing up on one of those days would be a real bummer, especially after a long drive.
You’ll find the shop at 300 S Lake Shore Way, Lake Alfred, FL 33850. Lake Alfred is a small Polk County town in central Florida, surrounded by lakes and citrus country.
That location makes it an easy detour for folks traveling between Orlando and Tampa. A quick stop can break up a long highway stretch nicely.
Hours can occasionally shift, so double-check before heading out. That’s especially true around holidays.
Pack a cooler bag with ice packs for butter, eggs, and milk. Then you can browse without worrying about the trip home.
9. Gift Baskets Practically Build Themselves Here
Stumped on a gift for the person who has everything? A trip down these aisles might solve that problem in about ten minutes.
Start with a jar of local orange blossom honey. It’s a true taste of Florida, and it travels well for out-of-town friends.
Add a jar of jam or cinnamon apple butter next. Toss in a bag of egg noodles or popcorn kernels for a fun, homey touch.
Bee pollen or a unique honey variety can make the basket feel extra special. Those are items most people won’t find at their usual grocery store.
Wrap everything in a simple basket or box with a ribbon. Suddenly you’ve got a thoughtful gift that feels handpicked, because it was.
These baskets work for teachers, neighbors, hosts, and holiday swaps. They also make a sweet thank-you for anyone who helped you out.
Of course, nobody says you can’t build one for yourself. Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse makes treating yourself feel pretty reasonable, and honestly, you deserve the good jam.









