We Came for the Amish Ice Cream but This Florida Shop’s Biscoff Menu Stole the Show

What if I told you one of Orlando’s most tempting dessert spots is hiding in a little shopping plaza near UCF? And we’re not talking about ordinary ice cream. Imagine thick, velvety Amish-style scoops buried under layers of Biscoff cookie butter, warm bubble waffles dripping with pistachio chocolate, and sundaes so loaded you’ll have trouble finding the ice cream underneath.

That’s what you’ll find at Ice Screamin Orlando, a colorful dessert shop on University Boulevard that’s turning simple ice cream runs into full-blown sugar adventures. With more than 30 flavors, trendy Dubai chocolate creations, and desserts that look almost too ridiculous to finish, this is one place where ordering just a single scoop might be your biggest mistake.

1. Amish-Style Ice Cream With a Rich, Creamy Base

Creamy is a word people toss around too easily, but here it actually fits. Amish-style ice cream is known for a dense, velvety texture, and the scoops at Ice Screamin show it off. Reviewers keep calling the ice cream fresh, rich, and full of flavor.

The shop offers more than 30 flavors, mixing classic favorites with seasonal picks. That list can make choosing feel like a test, so ask for a taste before you commit. The staff is patient while you decide, which helps a lot when a whole family is debating.

One visitor from New York said it was the best ice cream they had found in Florida, and that is a bold claim from someone who grew up with serious scoop shops. Another called it the best within fifty miles. Fans say you can taste the homemade quality in every bite.

Here is a simple plan for first timers. Start with a flavor you already love, because it makes a fair comparison to other shops. Then add one wild card, like toasted coconut, to see what else the freezer holds.

Portions are generous, so sharing is smart if you want to try more than one thing. Grab a cup instead of a cone if the Florida heat is winning. Melted ice cream is still delicious, but a spoon is easier.

2. The Biscoff Sundae That Hides Cookie in Every Bite

One reviewer said they had no idea how the shop got Biscoff into every single spoonful. That is the whole magic of this sundae. Cookie butter, crunchy cookie bits, and creamy ice cream are layered so no bite is plain.

Biscoff is that caramelized, spiced cookie many people first met on airplanes. Here it gets a starring role instead of a tiny cameo. The flavor is warm and toasty, a bit like gingerbread meeting caramel.

Texture matters, and this sundae delivers it. You get smooth ice cream, sticky sauce, and a crisp crunch from the cookie pieces. Each part keeps its own personality instead of turning to mush.

If you are a Biscoff fan, treat this as the main event of your visit. Order it early in your stay so you have time to circle back for more. A shared sundae works well, though you may end up guarding your side of the cup.

Eat it soon after it arrives. The cookie crunch is best before the ice cream softens too much. Grab extra napkins, because cookie butter has a way of finding your sleeve.

3. Dubai Chocolate Treats Worth the Hype

Dubai chocolate was the most talked about item in the reviews, with fourteen mentions. The idea is simple and clever: pistachio cream and crispy knafeh pastry wrapped in chocolate. It adds crunch, nutty flavor, and a little show-off sparkle.

At Ice Screamin, the chocolate is made in house, and it shows up on more than one menu item. Try it on a brownie, a donut, or a waffle. One guest loved a warm, fudgy Dubai brownie with vanilla ice cream, saying every bite was worth it.

The mix works because of contrast. Warm brownie meets cold ice cream, while the knafeh adds a crackly bite. Pistachio brings a gentle, earthy sweetness that balances the milk chocolate.

If you have seen this trend flooding your social feed and wondered whether it lives up, a visit here gives a fair answer. The reviewers certainly think so. Many came back for seconds before heading home.

Pick one Dubai item and pair it with a plain scoop of vanilla. That keeps the flavors clear and lets the pistachio shine. Bring a friend, since these desserts are rich and fun to split.

4. Bubble Waffles Fresh From the Iron

Before you even see the menu, your nose finds the waffles. Guests mention the smell of freshly baked batter the second they walk in. It is a sneaky, sweet welcome.

Bubble waffles are puffy, egg-shaped pockets joined together. The outside turns crisp and golden while the inside stays soft and fluffy. That makes them ideal for holding ice cream, fruit, and sauces.

The Dubai Bubble Waffle gets lots of love. It comes with melted chocolate, pistachio sauce, crushed pistachios, and crispy knafeh. Vanilla ice cream and whipped cream finish it off.

One happy visitor described the waffle as warm and crispy outside, soft inside, and loaded with toppings. Twelve reviewers brought up bubble waffles, so it is clearly a crowd favorite. Order one for the table and tear off pieces like a dessert pizza.

Timing helps here. Eat the waffle while it is still warm, because the contrast with cold ice cream is the best part. If you are bringing little ones, ask for lighter toppings so the sticky factor stays manageable.

5. Cheesecake Chunks and Smash Burger Creations

Dessert that looks like dinner always gets a double take. One reviewer ordered the Smash Burger treat made with cheesecake ice cream and called it delicious. The fun twist is a sweet stack that plays on a classic burger shape.

What really won them over were the small cheesecake bites mixed into the ice cream. Nine reviewers mentioned cheesecake chunks, so this is no fluke. The pieces add a tangy, creamy chew that plain scoops cannot match.

Think of it as a slice of cheesecake that learned how to be ice cream. The base stays smooth, and the chunks give you something to find with each spoonful. It is playful without being too much.

This is a smart pick for people who do not love super sugary desserts. Cheesecake has a gentle tang that keeps things balanced. Add a drizzle of sauce if you want extra sweetness.

Kids tend to love the burger presentation, and adults enjoy the surprise. Snap a photo before the first bite, because it melts fast in Florida air. Then tell everyone at the table to grab a spoon.

6. Mini Pancakes, Donuts, and Other Sweet Extras

Ice cream might be the headline, but the supporting cast is strong. Reviewers talk about mini pancakes, donuts, waffles, crepes, and loaded milkshakes. Several said the shop has far more than just ice cream.

The Dubai Mini Pancakes got big praise from one family. They were topped with chocolate and pistachio sauce and paired with strawberries and bananas. The kids were obsessed, and the fruit kept it from feeling too heavy.

Donuts stuffed with ice cream are another popular choice, including a peanut butter smashed donut. One guest wished for a warm glazed donut instead of a cold cake-style one. That is a fair note, so ask about the donut style before ordering if that matters to you.

The Fruity Pebbles cones were a hit with children too. Colorful, crunchy, and fun, they make dessert feel like a party. Sweet tooth squad, take note.

The menu also lists cookies, cake slices, sodas, juices, and bottled water. That makes it easy for a group with mixed cravings. Everyone can find something, even the friend who says they are not hungry.

7. A Bright, Happy Shop With Seats to Spare

Walk in and the colors hit first. Visitors describe summery decor, cheerful touches, and a happy vibe that feels different from an ordinary scoop shop. The space is spotless, and many reviewers also mention that it smells great.

There is plenty of seating, which matters more than people think. You are not hovering by the door with a melting sundae. Families, friends, and groups can spread out and stay awhile.

The shop sits on the corner of University Boulevard and Dean Road, close to UCF in East Orlando. That makes it handy for students and neighbors. A fun theme and roomy layout also work well for birthday outings.

Photos come easy here. The desserts are colorful, the room is bright, and the presentation is tidy. Bring your phone, but eat before everything starts melting.

One reviewer said the place felt like a breath of fresh air. That fits the energy. It feels more like a hangout than a quick stop.

8. Friendly Owners and Late-Night Hours

Service can make or break a dessert run, and this crew gets glowing marks. Reviewers describe owners with huge smiles and staff who seem excited to help. Welcoming staff came up thirteen times, while friendly owners earned seven mentions.

People say the team is patient while you decide and happy to explain the menu. That is a gift when there are more than thirty flavors and a long list of treats. A visitor from New York even planned a second stop before catching a flight home.

Hours are another bonus. The shop opens at 12:30 PM every day. It stays open until midnight Monday through Thursday and until 1 AM Friday through Sunday.

Those late hours suit college students, night owls, and families after a movie. You can also swing by after dinner without rushing. Call 321-295-7626 if you want to check on anything before you go.

The address is 10165 University Blvd, Orlando, FL 32817. Parking and seating are easy to manage, according to guests. Go hungry, bring friends, and save room for the Biscoff.